6 of the Most Romantic Restaurants in St. Augustine

One of the most romantic things to do in St. Augustine, FL, is to enjoy a delicious meal with your loved one. Luckily, there are some incredible fine dining restaurants just steps away from our front door. Whether you’re searching for some incredible Spanish cuisine or fresh local seafood, we can help you! Choose from our recommendations for the most romantic restaurants in St. Augustine.

Looking for other great things to do in St. Augustine for couples? Access our free Vacation Guide! You’ve got everything you need to spark some great St. Augustine date ideas, like a trip to one of the local spas or a tour at the local chocolatier. You’ll also find more great suggestions for the most romantic restaurants in St. Augustine.

The Most Romantic Restaurants in St. Augustine

Catch 27

Catch 27 is dedicated to showcasing incredible and delicious locally-caught seafood. Everything on the menu is cooked from scratch with seasonal ingredients and local produce. The fish, shrimp, and clams are caught in Florida waters and delivered fresh every day. The menu showcases classic Southern seafood dishes that have been elevated. Try the deviled egg BLT with a southern-fried oyster for a starter. For an entree, you can’t go wrong with a buttermilk fried chicken sandwich!

Michael’s Tasting Room

One of the more modern restaurants in the area, Michael’s Tasting Room features a casual fine-dining experience that’s Spanish inspired. Choose from a selection of tapas or bocadillos (sandwiches served on a chewy bread). For the main plate (or raciones), the daily catch is always sure to delight. Make sure to save room for one of the classic desserts on the menu, like flan or a creamy Spanish rice pudding.

Columbia Restaurant

Visit the oldest restaurant in Florida during your St. Augustine Vacation! Columbia Restaurant has been in operation for over 110 years and isn’t slowing down anytime soon. Columbia Restaurant’s menu is comprised of classic Spanish and Cuban fare, like the Gazpacho Andalucia or the red snapper a la rusa. If you want to nibble, select from the many tapas available, like the gambas al ajillo (Spanish-style shrimp sauteed with garlic) or croquetas de langosta (croquettes made with lobster meat). Don’t miss visiting this Florida staple!

La Pentola Restaurant

La Pentola is dishing up old world charm with classic French and Italian cuisine. Try one of the incredible seafood pastas, like the lobster ravioli or the salmon pasta. If you’re feeling adventurous, try the escargot for a starter. If deliciously sauteed snails aren’t your style, the ceviche de camaron (shrimp ceviche) is a great option.

Cellar 6 Restaurant

You’ll definitely want to make a reservation at Cellar 6 .This popular spot is modeled after the California Wine Bar and serves urban cuisine in a casual upscale environment. The menu features delicious flatbreads, Southern classics like shrimp and grits, and a dessert selection that’s sure to set the mood!

Collage Restaurant

As their motto says, “At Collage, it’s all about quality.” The eclectic menu reflects the tastes of the owners, Mike Hyatt and Cindy Stangby. Collage focuses on fresh local seafood, steaks, lamb, and veal, all perfectly prepared using international flavor profiles. The wine list is just as incredible as the food. The menu is meticulously curated to be reasonably priced and delicious.

Stay at Agustin Inn

After you’ve enjoyed some of the most romantic restaurants in St. Augustine, stay at the most romantic bed and breakfast in town! Agustin Inn is the perfect way to end your day. Our luxurious accommodations are sure to set that romantic mood. Consider booking Windsor, one of our most popular suites. It features a king-sized bed, oval-shaped Jacuzzi tub and shower, and a private balcony.

Make your romantic vacation extra special with one of our incredible packages. The Agustin Classic Romance Package includes a private horse and carriage ride from the Inn, a half-dozen assorted roses, a half-dozen chocolate-covered strawberries, and a gift certificate to one of St. Augustine’s signature restaurants. The Ultimate Romance Package is just as impressive, featuring a private horse and carriage ride, a half-dozen chocolate covered strawberries, champagne on ice, a dozen assorted roses, and a flameless candle for your room.

Check our availability and book your room today! We look forward to having you.